Retail vs. Prop Trading: Key Differences

Written By
G. Dautovic
November 16,2023

A growing number of individuals are venturing into active trading today, as technology democratizes the market and people are more eager to test themselves in day trading rather than passive trading through things like mutual funds.

If you are one of those aspiring traders, right now your options are to go either with retail trading or proprietary trading accounts, and this article will explain the differences and advantages that each of these trading spheres have, with the goal of informing you to make the best choice possible for your current trading needs.

Differences Between Retail and Proprietary Trading Accounts

These are some of the most notable ways that these two trading types differ from one another:

Access to Capital and Resources

Retail traders typically enter the markets using their own capital, and these days most commonly through one of the online day trading platforms, which inherently limits their trading scope. This self-funding nature necessitates a cautious approach, as personal assets are directly at risk.

Conversely, prop traders enjoy the backing of their firms, accessing substantial capital and state-of-the-art trading tools. This difference extends beyond just the scale of operations; it fundamentally alters risk management strategies and the potential for significant returns.

Regulatory Environment and Requirements

Retail traders face a simpler, albeit more restrictive, regulatory framework. The rules governing them are designed for public protection, often constraining their trading activities.

Prop traders, aligned with larger institutions, navigate a more intricate regulatory maze. These regulations are rigorous but provide certain trading liberties under the umbrella of a regulated prop firm, allowing for more aggressive trading strategies.

Level of Professional Training and Support

Another pronounced difference lies in the level of professional training and support. Retail traders are largely self-taught, supplemented by online resources and community forums.

In contrast, prop traders benefit from comprehensive training programs, mentorship, and continuous support provided by their firms.

This professional backing is invaluable in effectively navigating complex market environments.

Profit Sharing and Compensation Structures

The solitary nature of retail trading means individual profits and losses. The drive here is personal financial gain.

Prop trading, however, is often characterized by profit-sharing models. This arrangement allows prop traders to engage in larger trades with reduced personal financial exposure, aligning their success with that of the firm.

Risk and Reward Expectations

Risk tolerance and reward expectations vary markedly. Retail traders, using personal funds, typically adopt a conservative approach to risk.

Prop traders, equipped with more resources and advanced risk management systems, can pursue higher-risk, higher-reward strategies.

This fundamental difference in risk appetite significantly influences the respective trading styles and strategies.

Market Access and Trading Platforms

Retail traders often have limited market access, restricted to standard trading platforms and conventional asset classes.

Prop traders, however, can access a wider range of markets, including less traditional and more sophisticated instruments, thanks to the resources and technologies provided by their firms.

Decision Autonomy and Strategy Implementation

Lastly, retail traders have complete autonomy in decision-making, allowing them flexibility but also exposing them to the challenges of isolated decision-making.

Proprietary traders, while benefiting from broader resources, often have to adhere to firm-imposed strategies and risk parameters, which can limit their individual trading styles.

Bottom Line

In summary, retail and prop trading offer distinct pathways into financial markets, each with unique characteristics in terms of capital access, regulatory constraints, training, compensation, risk tolerance, market access, and decision-making autonomy.

For aspiring traders, understanding these differences is vital in choosing a path that aligns with their financial goals, resource availability, risk appetite, and desire for professional support and market access.

About author

I have always thought of myself as a writer, but I began my career as a data operator with a large fintech firm. This position proved invaluable for learning how banks and other financial institutions operate. Daily correspondence with banking experts gave me insight into the systems and policies that power the economy. When I got the chance to translate my experience into words, I gladly joined the smart, enthusiastic Fortunly team.

More from blog